JPF Home Page Forums General Messages General Message Forum American Idol 2009

They keep trashing Alison and driving her into the bottom 3. They had nothing bad they could say about her performance, so they spent a huge amount of time slamming her.. for her clothes... I don't get why they are against the idea of a great young singer with a bright future ahead of her doing well? She's not going to win.. that's a 1 horse race with 3 second tier folks vying for who will compete with Adam in the top 2. (By the way, Adam can't lose on talent.. he can only lose on non-talent factors.. like if little girls who vote like one of the others better). Alison, Kris and Danny are all on equal footing and along with Adam are worlds above all the rest. But the judges seem to want Lil Rounds who sucks to be in that final 4 instead of Alison.. who needs another weak R&B wannabe singer? Didn't they learn anything from previous boring R&B singers? They don't have a country act this year so they can't mimic the success of Carrie Underwood, but they have Alison who CAN mimic the success in the Pop/Rock genres. But they just don't want her to do well. And it's clear that's not based on their opinions of her singing, but something else. Hmmmm.

Meagan was cannon fodder. So is Anoop. So is Scott. Scott is that contestant they have every year that is terrible but gets propped up for no apparent reason long enough to outstay his welcome. He has sung well exactly 1 time on the show and that was in Hollywood week. Since then he's been terrible. Even this week, his best, was cheesy and lame from start to finish.. but at least he wasn't out of tune the entire time.

So we'll watch the next few weeks as Anoop, Scott and probably Matt all go down. Sadly Alison may end up out with them.. even though she doesn't deserve to go. Then we'll have Danny and Kris trying to fight over the table scraps left after Adam is done eating then alive.

Brian