JPF Home Page Forums General Messages General Message Forum American Idol 2009

I thought the 3 best were:

Adam
Danny
Allison

I thought the 4 worst were:

Jorge
Scott
Anoop
Jasmine

All four of these need to be gone. None deserved to be in the finals in the first place and they all proved it last night. Scott is the weakest overall singers of everyone and though he had 1 good performance in Hollywood, he's now had 2 miserable ones. Jorge has sucked from the start and I can't figure out why anyone has supported him throughout. I realize they want diversity (remember Simon said they had to "cast" the show) but I refuse to believe there wasn't a single other male latin singer that wasn't better all year.

I thought Lil was completely forgettable. Sure, she sings okay, but who really cares?

Adam is a veteran performer/singer. He's been doing this a really long time. In terms of pop music, he's really at the upper end of the age bracket. Though he's impressive, I think that Allison is more impressive being that good at 16. I think she has the most raw talent of the girls and it's really a 3 horse race already between her and Danny and Adam. All 3 have different styles and approaches. Danny is very much another Taylor Hicks. Adam ventures off into being theatrical rather than musical a lot of time and it may cost him a bit over the long haul. Allison took an MJ pop song and made it a legitimate edgy rock song. Compared to the pretender Alexis trying to be a rocker at the end, Allison made her look silly.

Deserves to go: Jorge and Scott

Will Go: Anoop and Jorge.

Possible Upset: Kris or Matt in the bottom 3.