Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
You're right, it sucks.


Once again...that is your opinion and nothing more.

You, more than anyone here, seek the VALIDATION of your opinion and what you consider to be the actual truth concerning someone else's song. And your espoused reason is to enable the songwriter to actually learn from your truth and then...actually grow in their songwriting skills.

As for me, I am not sure that you actually possess a good working scope and knowledge of the actual truth of songwriting skills.
And your opinions may lead down irrelevant side roads if taken too seriously. E.g. I dont want to view my songwriting through a Springsteen biased lens.

If MAB with his broad range of experience in both the song industry and as a song teacher, gave advice here...I would study his advice. May not agree with all of it but I would study. Not yours though. I appreciate when you take the time to comment, but dont hang on every word. You post too many things that dont seemed reasoned.

BTW...I do not blame MAB for not posting to songs here. I think that there are sound reasons for him to refrain.

https://soundcloud.com/sunset-poet-of-texas