WE have been over it, but what YOU think its not how it IS

You can say audio critiques are ok, but song critiques are not, all you like it will NEVER be true.

The ONLY difference is YOU prefer to talk about audio, because you have NO INTEREST, in songwriting craft.

And YOU fail to UNDERSTAND that NOT EVERYBODY thinks this way

Its actually pretty funny that YOU think the topic was SETTLED, the LAST time it came up.

WHAT you are ACTUALLY saying is that NOBODY should post LYRICS here.

AND your MORONIC thesis that a SONG is ONLY a SONG if it SOUNDS good, is REDICULOUSLY STUPID.

if SOMEBODY goes to a BAR and sings The BEATLES Help, with the band, and the band is a halfway decent band, and the singer is a halfway decent singer, its STILL a great song, done by amateurs

The ONLY time your theory is correct, is if its SO bad that the singer annoys the listener, and its an UNLISTENABLE band

There is decent, average, good, great etc

The bad singers on American Idol are PICKED specifically cause they are SO bad its FUNNY

How bout YOU approach it how YOU want to, and Ill Approach it how I want to? But that WONT happen, You'll tell me how to listen to and assess a song.

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 03/11/21 08:08 PM.