Hi Kevin:

No offense taken. To answer your question from my perspective, there are more lyric writers because it seems to be the point where a significant portion of songwriters begin. Many have little or no experience in writing or performing melodies. Most cannot play an instrument of any kind but still have a passion for contributing to music in whatever way they can.

Learning to be a good lyricist requires a great deal of work... and true, it is best if the lyricist undertakes a strategy to learn an instrument of some type and to learn the basics of music.

I began as a lyricist only and decided that I wanted more control of my work. I learned to play chords and began to sing, which to me, was the most daunting task of all. Co-writing is a wonderful experience depending upon the chemistry of those involved. If the chemistry is wrong... it is an absolute nightmare.

Most of what I have read and learned about songwriting is that the melody is the most important aspect of the song... but it can be left hanging and largely ignored unless accompanied by a good set of lyrics. Nothing against a good instrumental tune but a good song requires excellent lyrics to bring the melody to fruition. Both contributors are important and, to me, it is significantly easier if the two parts are handled by one person... unless, as Marc B. has stated, there is a very good working relationship where both parties work together efficiently, punctually and on a business-like basis.

Given a choice (with a few important exceptions) I prefer to write and compose alone. The logistics are simpler and I can blame nobody but myself if the song is not brought "to life" within the target date established for release, recording or simply pitching to others.

There is no best way... just whatever works best for the individual(s) involved.

Regards,

Dave

http://www.ShowCaseYourMusic.com/DaveRice