Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
As opposed to, nice job, pleasant melody.

The people in that thread were all into it, into songwriters, interested in helping the writer push if needed

Marty's ideas of reviews are useless


As stated a thousand times,

My belief is that, I can only tell someone how to write my songs, in accordance with my sensibilities and interest. I do not believe myself to be a qualified "instructor."
So I don't start breaking people's work down and re-building it for them. It's theirs, not mine.

But I desire to encourage them in some way...so when I hear something that I genuinely like, I MAY make a suggestion....light and short...but at the least, I'll say that "I enjoyed listening."
What other people say is up to them.
Most people leave a comment and move on.

But not you.
You harangue them.
And, is the price of that annoyance worth paying because of your years of experience writing hits for radio artists?
No. It's just a troll on a website being allowed to harass participants.

https://soundcloud.com/sunset-poet-of-texas