Originally Posted by Martin Lide
Goal #1 of a song should be appeal. Whatever makes a song appealing is a good thing. The primary consideration for a song is the music. If that doesnt work, it isnt a good song.

My suggestion...do whatever or employ whomever that makes your song as appealing as you can make it.
Still no guarantee that anyone else will notice or care, but you will.

Martin


I agree, but hes talking about basic feedback on a song. An acoustic guitar and scratch vocal should be enough for songwriters. but it seems now everybody wants to hear full demos.