Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Originally Posted by Martin Lide
Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Originally Posted by Martin Lide
Whether a single instrument or a full production, the music, vocals and whatever else is there, has to be appealing.

As someone wrote on one of these sites years ago..."no groove, no song."


Depends what type of song it is. if its a lyric featured song, it can still make an impact, so long as the melody is good. if its a groove featured song obviously it cant.



Those are possible trees.
The forest..."no groove, no song."

Not my quote.


It's very hard for a song to be any good without everything working, I agree with that. And alot of what we think of as a great song is a combination of melody, lyric, arrangement, perfomance, production. But pure songwriters deal with the melody and lyric. So sometimes they are asking for feedback on that alone, a regular listener of music doesnt have the capacity to know a good song without a big presentation.

I think Neil is just looking to see if his ideas are good.


True.

But he is concerned about a lack of responses. So...

https://soundcloud.com/sunset-poet-of-texas