Kevin,
I really enjoyed reading your "initial thoughts" (report) about your experience with OurStage. I've been testing it out a bit myself in the last few days, posting a few songs for contents, two short music videos and judging a few channels.

Regarding your 8th point:
8.) One step to make it more "unbiased" would be to NOT show what songs are going against each other -- "blind" sound tests.

I would have to agree with you! Matter of fact, some of the artist/band images tend to "hurt" the songwriter's more than help. For example, some are very bad looking graphics, yet the song might actually sound better than the pix looks, or worse, the image looks like a "big dollar" campaign, but then the music falls totally flat; that's usually the most common scenario. But to clarify, if I hear a GREAT song I will still give it proper voting credit (+) even though the graphic image falls short. However, I might feel diff. when judging music videos, because I'm more likely to expect some nice visual images.

For example, as a judge I'd like to have a way to qualify my ties between two songs. Currently, when it's a "draw", the two songs could be either: equally great, equally average or equally bad. Now there's NO way to specify. This is a bit disturbing especially if both songs were totally "0" on a scale of 1 to 10!

In case of ties (equal matches or draws) between two songs, it would be nice if they gave judges three more options (radio buttons) to choose from, for example:
a) Pretty bad.
b) Ok, about average.
c) Terrific!

Remember, both songs in a Draw are going to be equally the same, it's just a question of bad, Ok, or great!

You also made some good points on point 2:
2.) I reported about five or six songs as being "Off-topic" -- they just didn't belong in the country category. I also reported one as a copyright violation. A lady was doing a medley of past country hits by women. She may have paid for the mechanicals, but they were covers -- I want to judge originals.

I think it's great that they give us judges the "power" to help them catch "Off-topic" songs as well as copyright violations. Also, maybe they can open up a "Covers" channel for artists that are mostly performing cover songs with instruments (instrumentals) and/or with vocals. I know, it would be similar to Karaoke, but at least they'd be in the right channel as performers that didn't also write their own original lyrics and tunes. So that might solve some of the percieved copyright "problems", but legally, those performers would still need to get some kind of mechanical license (I think) or purchase commercial Karaoke tracks that they can legally use to enter into these kinds of online contests.

While we're on the topic, I also have two questions for you, or anyone that wants to help me with these.

1. How many people per month can actually win the big $5,000 cash award? I mean, is it just 1 person from all the channels, or is it 1 person per channel, for example, the 1st place for each Channel? From my understanding, I'm lead to believe that it's one artist from each channel, but I might be off on that.

2. How does OurStage pay for all the cash prize costs?
I know last year they were charging the judges a fee to vote in the final rounds. I think they changed this, so evidently now it's FREE for all judges to vote, evidently even in the final rounds.

Maybe they generate revenue from sponsors, ads and/or song sales, but I haven't seen any ads around the site, and so far they are offering to pay out 100% to the artists for their song download sales.

3. Finally, I can see my current song ratings, but I can't find where they show how many songs are currently entered into that Channel. Maybe you can point me to the right "page" where I can get those stats. If my song is 100 out of 120, it's no big deal, but if it's 100 out of 1,200 it's a lot more important to know.

Thanks!
Michael


There's nothing remarkable about it. All one has to do is hit the right keys at the right time and the instrument plays itself. -- Johann Sebastian Bach

MichaelBorges.com
LicenseQuote.com