I spent some time over the last couple of days "judging" songs at OurStage.com -- I've done 41 head to head challenges. I know, I know, I am supposed to be working on my FAWM or RPM songs or reviewing Scott's song in the Mentor program!

My initial thoughts:

1.) Being a "home recordist", I do make allowances for some recording issues. However, if the song is all out of the left speaker or very poor recording quality -- fergetaboutit! If you want to have your songs judged positively, you got try and bring your "A" game.

2.) I reported about five or six songs as being "Off-topic" -- they just didn't belong in the country category. I also reported one as a copyright violation. A lady was doing a medley of past country hits by women. She may have paid for the mechanicals, but they were covers -- I want to judge originals.

3.) Don't let "Big Jim" listen to the country selections -- there was a lot of "crap" in there (LOL). Seriously, I pay more attention to lyrics nowadays and there are tons of trite, overused phrases, words stuck in just to rhyme, weak story lines, and so on. Plus about half the songs are snoozers -- slow tempo, sappy tunes destined for mark's graveyard of songs.

4.) I don't know about songwriter's posting pro demos of their songs yet. Maybe it was Moker's song in there that made me think about it. I sort of want the "artist" name to be the one performing it. However, since I'll never really know who is who, I'll just have to let this slide. So this opens the whole OurStage thing to writers that don't perform -- but you have to pay for some kind of demo first.

5.) We talked about getting pro critiques in another thread -- well this is probably a great first step. Take a good song you've written, do the best home demo you can do (or just guitar/vocal) and put it up on OurStage. If you can get into the top 10%, then maybe you have something there. If you already have a pro demo, stick it in there. You have to get to the top 10% (or in the top 10) if the song really has any "legs". Not a perfect "review", but probably the most unbiased you will get.

6.) Well, it is not totally unbiased. Although OurStage says they are "scam" proof, any group with more Internet "friends" are going to get more votes and attention. ... And I'm OK with that. That's the real world. If these acts have worked hard to get a following and that following will get in there and vote for them, more power to them. Of course, those friends have to wade through a bunch of other songs to actually judge those "friend" tunes.

7.) I put "There's A drought Going On" in there. Now I brought my "A" game -- but it's me singing for crying out loud! I sort of felt that if I could get to 50th percentile on this one, I was doing OK. I think I got to the high 130's (out of 266 songs), so I sort of met my goal. At first it was stuck near last and I was getting depressed. Of course, it is better to get depressed at OurStage instead of sinking thousands of dollars on pro demos and get depressed in Nashville. Next month I'll try and make recording of my best two or three songs and stick them in there. If I can get into the top 10%, then I will consider paying for the pro critiques and getting real demos made. I know OurStage may not be an accurate indicator of anything, but it seems to be better than anything else out there for getting "unbiased" feedback.

8.) One step to make it more "unbiased" would be to NOT show what songs are going against each other -- "blind" sound tests.

I think that's all for now.

Kevin



"Good science comes in peer reviewed journals. Conspiracy theories come in YouTube videos. "
Kevin @ bandcamp: Crows Say Vee-Eh