Perhaps a better way of judging would be a scale of quality for both songs EG very poor, poor,average,good,very good, excellent and on a head to head the song with the highest rating wins. As it is there is no way of telling how good or bad songs are just how they compare to each other. It would appear that this randomisation of judging could give certain songs an unfair advantage.
Another point is the one mans meat thing. Unless all songs are judged how can your opinion about only a few songs be counted as balanced.
There does not appear to be a way to vote for your fav song. However we know that ther are probs with this judging method as well.