I don't get into entering contests. I just go by overall ratings over the course of many sites as well as comments. And then I take that into consideration for my next batch of recordings.
But it looks almost from having songs rated at Broadjam once like that may be more in line of the close to perfect voting standard. Though that may be a vague example.
Maybe categories of originilaity, knowing the standards, as well as performance (playing, being in tune) should be rated on a scale of 1 to 10 through a collective vote from forum members.
But going beyond some basic essential table of categories would get very confusing with how subjective that could get.