My experience is similar. I have judged about 300 songs now.

Several only had sound in the left or right side; I found some electronica and Club/Dance in the Jazz category and flagged it. I found one song that ripped off a Led Zepplin riff for it's intro and flagged that one.

I find a fair number that are mis-categorized.

It definitely pays to make sure your song is mixed and mastered well since there are definitely some professionally-mastered songs in the competition. I've downgraded a few songs simply because they were unlistenable with a biting guitar or sax tone (almost painfully bright), or they were so compressed that the pumping sound was totally distracting. I'm getting a feeling of what the TAXI critiquers might go through.

However, the cream does rise to the top. If you listen to just about any of the monthly winners, you'll hear music that's decidedly better than what comes out on radio these days.

As an experiment, I entered a jazz tune I recorded about 6-7 years ago the other day. It entered at #217 and in 3 days it's moved down to #202. Only 17 people have listened to it though, so I don't think there are as many listeners in the Jazz genre.

I've been mainly judging Jazz, Pop, Acoustic and R&B.

Interestingly, my own song has come up only ONE time for me to judge in all those listenings.