Liszt makes good reason in technical terms, and assumes that because it's there in writing, the court proceedings should go accordingly. SWman says that court is court and EVERYTHING in court is subject to interpretation and whims of who is hearing them, as well as his last GREAT point of winning nothing because your opponent goes belly up.

Anyone who has been divorced and gone through the bull%&^ in court knows that NOTHING is sacred, even if it's in writing! People fight and fight over stuff out of principle and usually spend more than they are fighting about. the outcome is usually gray.I remember one of those court TV shows where the judge says "I know I made a good ruling when NOBODY is happy".

SWman says the odds that Michael Jackson (or someone who has ALOT of money) will be the one to steal your song, then you suing them and winning even if you have the proper copywrite, are so slim your money would/may be better off spent elsewhere.

Given MY court experience in other fields, and reading this thread about how tenuous copywrite law is, I believe he makes sense.

Did I make this into English and a sensible interpretation?

Herbie


Herbie
JPF Chicago Chapter Coordinator
http://www.herbietunes.com