Liszt:

Your good advice vs. best advice statement pretty much sums up your belief that statutory law is somehow etched in stone, and that not following it to the letter is somehow not playing by the rules.

Truth is, the rule of law, statutory or otherwise, must be applied rationally to each case. If a songwriter can afford to follow the "letter of the law" and immediately file a copyright registration for each and every song, if and when published, that will, no doubt, provide the greatest statutory protection from infringement. Buying flight insurance before every flight may also be considered by some as "best" advice if you absolutely, positively, want to cover all your bases.

Not following the procedures of Title 17 to the letter, however, will not ever change who wrote the song and when they wrote it, despite whomever gets a registration for the song.

You asked, "Does or does not timely registration within 5 years of publication as prescribed by law help your chances of winning a case? Yes or No? I say yes, because the registration filed within 5 years is automatically given weight that the rest of the evidence must overcome."

In answer to your question, you must be willing to acknowledge the obvious. The registration only presumes that what has been stated in the application is true. So if someone can "prove" to the court that they actually wrote the song prior to the date stated by the author in the application, the prima facie evidence then works against the registrant.

Your arguments are not new and they do have merit, but this is not a matter of good advice vs. great advice, just two different approaches.

I would simply ask the readers of this thread to ask themselves a few simple questions and then draw their own conclusions.

How many songs have you had published?

How many of those songs have you registered with the copyright office within three months of publication?

How much money have you spent filing copyright applications and sending in recorded songs to the copyright office?

How many of your copyrighted and registered songs have been infringed?

It's your money. Spend it as you will.