*** the following is only my opinion and should not be taken as legal advice. I am not a lawyer.... ***

Songwriterman,

You have enlightened me with some new thinking on the copyright subject and with the apparent angles taken in the real world with regards to copyright and the court. For that I thank you.

But, I do still have to argue a couple of points. I would argue that just like learning how to do anything else, an aspiring songwriter should learn and strictly follow all the "rules". After that, if they want to play with breaking them, then fine. The "rules" as read strictly from copyright law and as taught to most songwriters, is to immediately register a published work, within three months of publication. Also, another reason for an aspiring songwriter to strictly follow the rules would be that most are not going to have the benefit of legal counsel or the benefit of experience such as yours, where they may be able to judge correctly when to break the rules or not.

There is the issue of good advice and best advice. Your advice may be good, but following the "rules" is the best advice. And I still cannot believe a copyright lawyer would not agree with that.

The second thing I would argue is this: Does or does not timely registration within 5 years of publication as prescribed by law help your chances of winning a case? Yes or No? I say yes, because the registration filed within 5 years is automatically given wieght that the rest of the evidence must overcome. After 5 years it is up to the court what wieght to give the registration.

Definition of prima facie from LAW.COM:

"Latin for "at first look," or "on its face," referring to a lawsuit or criminal prosecution in which the evidence before trial is sufficient to prove the case unless there is substantial contradictory evidence presented at trial...

Also, although I believe you when you say that statutory fines and attorney's fees that are possible only with registration of a published work within 3 months of publication are often not awarded, the RIAA in it's internet file sharing suits are asking for just those things. And, they couldn't if the registrations had not been filed within 3 months of publication. In fact, one could make an arguement that the RIAA's lawsuits would not be possible if they did not have statutory fines to rely on(and those would not be possible if they had not filed registrations within 3 months), because it would be too hard to prove and not nearly as cost effective to sue for damages only.

And...because you are REQUIRED to make a deposit with the Library of Congress within 3 months of any published item related to music, it would make sense at the time (although it is not required) to register something at that time - the SR or PA, whatever fits the particular case...

Everyone has to make there own choices about this registration stuff...


[This message has been edited by Liszt Laughing (edited 09-09-2003).]


Boo...my name is Doug