Liszt:

You stated, "Although I don't think you meant it this way, that would be really bad advice for published material, as you lose significant rights if you don't file for registration of those materials within three months of publication."

The three month rule you mention does apply to published works and certain statutory remedies that MAY be unavialable to the plaintiff thereafter in FEDERAL Court only, such as attorney fees that MAY be awarded but frequently aren't, and certain statutory remedies that MAY also be awarded but frequently aren't.

"Could you explain in more detail how a person could win an infringement case by registering the material after the alleged infringement?" was your next comment. your first misconception is the only legal recognition of a copyright claim in court is if it is registered. Not true!

The first person, fortunately that's usually the author, who places a c in a circle, author's name and date takes precedence over ANY party who may come in at a later date and file a copyright registration for that same work "claiming it is theirs," published or not.

Common law creation of one's rights to their creative output with the c in the circle, name and date take priority over Federal Statutory law.

In the situation you allude to, I would sue in Federal court under common law rather than statutory law and add fraud on the Copyright Office to my list of complaints before the court. Party A would prevail and party B may be going to jail.