Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by songwriterman:
My advice, and it is just that base on years of experience, is to save your money and forget about filing in the Copyright Office until, if ever, infringement occurs. Then is the time to submit an application for copyright registration with accelerated process and deal with the infringer appropriately.</font>


Hello songwriterman,

Although I don't think you meant it this way, that would be really bad advice for published material, as you lose significate rights if you don't file for registration of those materials within three months of publication. Plus, you are required to make a deposit of published materials.

I think you were referring to registering unpublished material. I do understand it is common for publishers not to do that, I understand true infringement is rare, and I understand what you are saying, but could you explain in more detail how a person could win an infringement case by registering the material after the alleged infringement? You have a song. Person A wrote it in 1998 and fixed it to a tangable medium. They play it out for friends at coffehouses, or, even more common now, puts it on a song site on the internet (which actually to my mind could be considered publishing the material - but that's another debate). Person B hears it and puts in in her memory, head or computer. In 2001, she records a CD with this song on it, registering the copyright as pubished material. In 2002, person A hears person B's single from the CD on the radio, and says - hey - I wrote that song - I think I'll sue. So, they dig up the 1998 demo, send it in with a registration (and would have to be filed as unpublished most likely). Now, being that the only legal recognition of a copyright claim in court is if it is registered, how is person A going to win against B if they have a registration that is newer than the registration date of B? I would like to hear in more detail why person A could possibly expect to win this case.

Thanks.



[This message has been edited by Liszt Laughing (edited 09-09-2003).]


Boo...my name is Doug