Originally Posted by Vicarn
What qualifications do I have? Have I written a couple of hits?To assume you know more than the person who wrote the song is arrogant.


I would have to disagree with this statement. First, the people who ask for critiques want to know what others think of their song. You are a human being from essentially the same culture so you are a potential audience member so of course I would want to know what you think. If you hate my song, I want to know why. You don't have to to rewrite it for me, but I value your opinion whether you have written a hit song or not.

Somebody said he doesn't want critiques which is fine, but when he has finally finished his song and possibly spent hundreds of dollars on a demo, what if everybody hates it? Oh crap - they don't understand the lyric - the $500 went down the drain because the music doesn't go with the lyric - and so on.

I need fresh ears.......

Colin

I try to critique as if you mean business.....

http://colinwardmusic.com/

http://rosewoodcreekband.com/