I can only imagine what must be going through Taylor Swift's mind today.
Even the major Newspapers are carrying this story. There was a comment in our local Nashville paper from her Label. They are trying to defend her but I'm not sure it's working.
I wonder what the fallout will be?
I have two Granddaughters and I have seen what loss of self Esteem can to to a young woman.
Personally I don't care if she can sing or not. The technology of today has allowed her to rise to the top of her profession. I wonder what is normally required of a person to rise to that level.
Do they have to be perfect in every aspect of what they do?
Singer Songwriter? Do they have to be a perfect guitar player? What if she was singing well but kept missing chords while playing? or simply played the wrong chord or couldn't keep time?
Of course it doesn't usually say singer/ songwriter/ Guitar player. But everyone does expect them to play guitar or piano. Or like McCartney, Bass.

Well, back to the question. How is Taylor Swift handling this. It must be devastating to her. First Kanye insults her with his little stunt but he was just saying what everyone else is saying now. Wasn't he?
Didn't Taylor get a Grammy for "Best Female Vocal Performance"? How embarrassing is that? And who is embarrassed? Her or the people that gave it to her. Are they wishing they could take it back.

When Taylor first burst on the scene I wasn't a big supporter. I didn't think she was that good a singer and I said so. Here. I also said her songwriting was good but not great.
I said she was the equivalent of the Teen stars of old. Frankie and Annette stories, etc. She's young, beautiful, and relates to the younger folks. She is totally believable. Her songs speak to teens in a way no one else is doing these days. Young Love, Teen Angst, Heartbreak being quelled by love in the end. Isn't that what all young people want? Uptempo songs of love and HOPE. The teens and young adults love her songs.

I thought the songs were good but basically they were the same song written over and over again with different words. Ha? Write something that's been written but say it a different way? Isn't that what they keep telling us?

I have come to realize that she IS a very good songwriter. Read the lyrics to Our song? Tim Mcgraw. You Belong to me.
Sorry but these IMHO are really very good.

Bottom line is the young folks out there love her. Both my Granddaughters sing her songs. They don't care if she uses autotune. All they care about is putting the stolen download into the CD player and listening to her songs. I did yell at them for stealing. (They did eventually buy a CD after I told them I was embarrassed for them and the sound on a Bought CD would be better.)
But in the end it is all about what the people want. What the buyers of Music want. Taylor was, if I am not mistaken, A hit on MySpace before she was a hit on Radio.

If it had been up to my parents in 1956 I would NEVER had been allowed to buy a 45 RPM of Love Me Tender. But they did let me buy Bill Haley's Rock around the clock. If they knew it was about sex I don't think they would have, LOL.

Finally
I wish I could write like that. I wish I could take the ideas that swim around in my head and write them down in a way that relate to people like Taylor's songs do.
Waylon Jennings comes to mind, too, when I think about this. What a way to say things. How about Kris. And of course Dylan whom everyone but me thinks is the best songwriter ever. Personally I don't see it. But that's just me. smile

So here we are
Arguing over whether a 19 Year old (20?) kid can sing or not.
Is that really what matters? Or is it more important that she has reached out and touched so many young people with her songs. I remember being 16 years old. I remember the uncertainty of my feelings. I worried about all number of things. I remember talking on the phone and trying to not be heard by my parents. I remember driving my 1950 ford convertible and my girlfriend's feet on the dash and her hair blowing in the wind.
Heck now I realize this Tayor Swift reached something in me too. And I am a worn out 65 year old man with nothing to look forward to but dieing.
Thanks Taylor for taking me back.



Bill
http://www.soundclick.com/billrobinson
http://www.dreamqueststudio.com
Skype; bill.robinson12

"The democracy will cease to exist when you take away from those who are willing to work and give to those who would not." --Thomas Jefferson didn't say it

http://voidnow.org/
http://www.americansworking.com/