Mike I agree with most of what you say....There is a big difference between having individual preferences, taste and choice and appreciating skill and talent from other genres and styles. Anyone who truly loves music should be able to spot talent and musical skills when they see it regardles of what kind of music that person is performing. It goes without saying that we should be able to spot weakness and know when acts fall short of the standard we would associate with stardom.
It is very hard in this topsy turvy industry to give someone with little talent any great acclaim or credit when people who we meet in every day life have oodles more talent yet receive zero reward or recognition.
I am not interested in how popular an act is or how much money they make or how famous they are I judge each on the merits of their ability and talent. Anyone can be a star...history has proved that...does not necessarily mean they are talented or deserving. This business is corrupt so we either beat them or join them.