LOL, Rick smile

Mike:

The use or abuse (depending on your viewpoint) of technology is a fascinating topic for discussion - One that I haven't participated much in with regards to music but I have in many other contexts.

For instance, when I was into photography there was always a debate about manipulated images. Someone would photoshop two subjects together that weren't together when the photo was taken. Someone says, "Hey that's cheating - you're manipulating reality". Someone else asks HIM, "Do you put a UV filter on your lens?" Isn't that cheating? Or what about photographing in black and white? The scene isn't in black and white. That's cheating! Heck, the sole act of capturing an image with a camera is cheating because the camera doesn't see things the same way the eye does. An on and on and on.....

I've seen climbers look down on other climbers who use chalk on their hands when climbing. Then you ask them if the sticky rubber shoes they are using aren't giving them a similar advantage. And you get a blank look..... smile

Problem is that there is practically a continuum of technological advances - and I guess it's up to each person to decide if there is a line that shouldn't be crossed. Given that, I probably should have said, "I would be embarrassed if I were one of those folks using autotune or lip synching". They don't have to be embarrassed at all. But I'd be....

Are there any absolutes? I don't know. Is the "presentation" all that matters? Or does it have to be real? I think folks don't mind (or at least even think about) whether the performance is real or not - until it goes out of control - Like the Ashlee Simpson debacle on Saturday Night Live. When that happens, it seems like folks either feel cheated, or heap scorn on the performer. Kinda like "Go ahead and amaze me with trickery - just don't let me see behind the curtain" smile

Bottom line - whatever technology folks are using to make themselves sound better? They're probably stuck with it for the rest of their performing lives - otherwise folks will see behind the curtain.

Taylor apparently (for now at least and I hope it stays that way) doesn't use a curtain and doesn't have a safety net. I like that about her. smile

Scott