I have participated in numerous threads on this issue over several years on various forums. I think that the genie is out of the bottle retort is correct. Why do I think that? (Meaning that we can't stop illegal downloading.)

First, people are greedy. If they can get something for free, they will always do that. I'm talking about the majority of the masses.

Even if a server is shut down in the USA, thanks to the breadth of the internet, someone can put up a server in Russia.

Secondly, the fact that MANY MUSICIANS FEEL THAT FINES AGAINST DOWNLOADING ARE SILLY OR WRONG should show us that...

...if LOTS of musicians think it's fine to download without paying, then my gosh, what are consumers' opinions going to be?

It's a very complicated situation we have now, I admit. But I personally think that if the RIAA continued to sue thousands of people and publicized these suits, it would deter downloading. Then again, most downloads are by teenagers and we know they don't have a brain yet, so, maybe I'm wrong. Put it this way, I think it would deter adults (who have something to lose) from illegal downloads.

I have toyed with this idea for my songs... customer sets the price but he must pay SOMEthing. Else, the download isn't triggered. The "ask for donations" model apparently does not work. Because almost nobody will actually donate. But if you MAKE someone donate SOMEthing before the download is triggered, I wonder if that would work.

Then again, that sounds like Magnatune. How has it done?