Originally Posted by Doug Heard
Just because something is the "law" doesn't make it right or moral. Slavery was the law for a long time.

Stupid law. Recorded music isn't real music go see someone perform. A recording of music has no more validity than you going to see me perform and come home and sing what you heard to your friend. You want to make money in music get on the damn stage.


Holy S___ Doug!
you mean lo these many years I've been buying imitation music...or worse yet...FAKE music?
good grief.... how is a copy of your recording remotely similar to my singing some of your own songs to one of my friends? (and forget the fact that my voice and yours are not similar)
you're talking apples and oranges

For those of us who don't perform... (or don't perform enough to make a living) to write us off as having nothing worth any money... gee thanks bub!
there is much that you often can't convey in a live performance (especially without your band or symphony orchestra backing you) and the same can be said about what you can convey usually in a recording... (the energy...)
to call one valid and the other not REAL.... that's absurd