Oct. 2. An amateur musician and 11 other jurors are seated to hear the case against a woman accused by a recording industry group and 3 recording companies with free-sharing 1,702 copyright protected works of music online. This is the first case to go to trial of 26,000 people sued by the industry. Her lawyer says they have not proven she did share the works. Others accused have paid a few thousand dollars to settle suits filed against them.

Is there an analogy for this? If you grow your own food so you don't need a farmer's food, that's not stealing. But if you take the farmer's food out of his field and give it to a customer who then doesn't have to pay the farmer, that's stealing. He worked to produce the food and before he could sell it to earn his investment back, with a profit, you stole it and gave it away. Does that analogy work to conceptualize what's happening? What would the farmer's motive to farm be if it was subject to theft on a scale canceling his profitability? If his product was easy to steal he'd have to invest his time in something else to enable survival. This trial could set a precedent one way or the other, either throwing the doors wide open for file-sharing your product, cutting you out of the picture, or for prosecuting those who do it.


There will always be another song to be written. Someone will write it. Why not you? www.garyeandrews.com