VERY interesting topic. The only rule I'm convinced of is that there are no rules, or rather there are tons of exceptions for every rule. For example, I've met a LOT of musicians who are also into programming computers. I'm a hobbyist programmer myself. And I know some top notch software engineers who couldn't carry a tune in a bucket. I know some really good artists who could never ever write a song, and some who are good at both music and art. I know guys who are very creative songwriters who also grew up taking stuff like tape decks apart and putting them back together.

There's only one type of person I've never met. I've never met someone who was both a superior athlete AND a really good musician. I know some musicians who have some athletic ability, but all of my friends who are really good athletes (or perhaps WERE really good when they were younger) are sort of non-musicians, or they play music but not proficiently.

I would not draw the conclusion that you can't be fantastic at both. I just find it odd that I've never met anyone who was fantastic at both. But I'm sure they're out there.

As far as what you pointed out... I do think that some people are real creative and it bothers them when they CAN'T be creative. Which would explain why a creative person would hate an assembly line job or a job where they can't use their creativity. Some jobs make it easy to be creative, like teaching 5th grade... there are millions of ways to teach stuff to kids and make it fun. But if you're fixing brakes, then yeah, you don't want someone trying new, creative ways to fix your brakes! smile

Another thing I've noticed is that, even as far back as college, the absolute best musicians I knew were NOT songwriters. I'm talking about guys who could play "Flight of the Bumblebee" on a trombone. I knew guys in college who could just plain flat out play ANYTHING. And none of those guys were interested in writing songs... aside from maybe some jazz pieces. They just weren't interested. Again, there are musicians out there who are best of class AND are great songwriters, but it sure seems like God doesn't hand out both to people too often.





Richard MacLemale
Music = http://www.richardmac.com