Jake:

Thanks for starting this interesting thread. Left brain, right brain... or no brain. Mechanical aptitude and musical aptitude sometimes seem diametrically opposed... but there are those who actually can do just about anything. It must be wonderful. If given the choice of being a great songwriter versus being a great musician, I'm not sure which direction I would take.

I absolutely love songwriting but would really love to be able to play well... especially by ear as in Jazz Pianist or Guitarist. I suspect that I would not do well as part of an orchestra. Seems too confining. Somehow, I relate music to soaring.

Thanks to everyone for your perspectives. Great thoughts.

All my best,

Dave Rice