Howdy all.

This whole discussion brings up some interesting stuff to me. Marc used the term "lottery ticket." Back in the early 90s I had lunch with a guy who cowrote a couple of number ones in the 70s and I used the same concept of songs as lottery tickets. I'm still looking for the winning one. :-)

I know back in those days it was easier to play my worktapes and feel comfortable with it. However, I was told by a guy I highly respect to get some demos done. The way I look at it now, being over 50 and very reticent to quit my job and move back to Nashville, I figure the chance to win the lottery is so slim I do it this way: Get a good singer and a/some good picker(s) to present the song to publishers. I have no illusions about playing my song for many A & R folks. That is more likely to happen by accident I think for me. Besides, I have a gambling problem and I can go crazy with spending money on lottery tickets/real expensive demos (which is $150 LOL). I'm not saying my way is the best way for anybody else but it is the best way for me at the present time. I figure my best shot is trough a publisher hearing my song but my singing and my playing won't cut it though. It has to be a better singer and picker, at least until the publisher likes me enough to allow me to do it.

If a publisher or certain people in these songwriting groups like JPF recommended more costly demos to better evaluate the song, I would do it but not before getting other people's inputs. I would always get critiques first before doing a demo that costs money. Some critiques I put more value in though I listen to them all. Like I said, I'm a gambler and I've learned I can't be objective. I always think I'll win but seldom do.

One of the things that's brought me to this point is something Paul Overstreet said someone told him. (He didn't tell me this face, he said it on TV.) He said he always believed if the song sounded good on just a guitar, you probably had a good song. I've heard you can't get a good uptempo groove on a piano but then I think of Jerry Lee Lewis and Elton John. Now, no one needs to tell me none of us are Jerry Lee or Elton John. But I have heard good songs sound good on one instrument if the picking and the singing were good--not necessarily great.

At all these writers in the rounds, how many instruments are there? It's usually one guitar and sometimes other guitars and maybe a keyboard join in. I don't know if those songs still sound great because we're familiar with them or because it's possible for good songs to sound good with one instrument but I enjoy hearing one good song on a guitar. Of course, I'm looking for entertainment and not trying to make a profit.
.
.
.