p.s. I'll add that if money is the issue I'd recommend paying for a top shelf professional gtr/voc rather than spending the same amount on non-pro full band demo (using amateur players to cut costs) any day and any time.

I just critiqed a song for a client that was a classic example of the demo being more of an obstacle than an attribute. I was really digging the guitar/voc 1st verse and thinking, "this is awesome!" Then the band kicked in and it was hard to listen through to the end. The guitar by itself was great and facilitated the song...the band was a 'one man midi band' thing and it was fairly hard to take. As much as I tried to hear through it I started not caring for the song itself because of the playing.

For songs that are brand new by writers seeking critique I actually request work tapes...voice and gtr into a cassette player. I find that if I suggest a rewrite, the writer who submitted a work tape is much more apt to embrace the notion than the writer who just paid $500-$1000 on a full band demo. Gee, I wonder why? ;>)

Work tapes are what staff writers submit to their publishers before a song gets demo'd, and in the evaluation stage of a song that's always been enough for me too. I'd rather hear the raw, bare bones, through the air to cassette creation first. I want to hear the chords, hear the melody and read the lyric...period. If a song passes that test I figure it's probably worth taking to the next step.

But ya can't pitch a work tape obviously. That surely goes without saying but I've suggested work tapes for evaluations in other threads and got railed for supposedly suggesting that a work tape could be pitched. Just wanted to clarify...thus the edit.

br
www.writethismusic.com

Last edited by billrocker; 04/01/09 03:28 PM.