Hey guys,

Lively discussion. Let me throw another wrinkle into it and since Ray, Bill, Billy, and Mike are on this, let me mention my full process I suggest to writers:

#1 First of all, write several songs. Don't just write one and get a full demo. Get some options, different types of songs, different co-writers, different styles.

#2 Do good work tapes or guitar vocals.
Using one or two music tracks, clear vocals, harmonies, possibly some precussion or bass, sometimes can move a song just enough to pass for a pitch possibility.
Bill, to answer your question, I had a song cut that I wrote with David Vincent Williams, Rescued Me" That was a nice guitar, multiple harmoines, precussion, light instrumentation. It was recorded by John Berry, and subsequently recorded around 9 times by independents and once by Toni Sol Fa, a Minnepolis based adult contemporary accapela group. So yes, that is a viable pitch without going full demo route.
Of course, writing a song with a number one writer like D Vincent (I'm Moving On, Just Got Started Loving You) don't hurt.

#3 Get evaluations on the best songs. Play them out, live with them, gague audience or friend's reaction, test on web sites, etc.

#4 Get full demos on the best of the best. Take time and study what goes on.

#5 Be aware of "outside the box" pitches. Local or regional artists, My Space, Face Book, You Tube sites, explore other avenues outside of the mainstream pitches. Attend local writers nights or open mics in search of collaborators or potential audiences.

#6 Make sure you have them on your own sites, explore as many ways as you can to get songs out there.

#7 Write more songs, repeat process.

The demo in this day and age represents more than just a pitch on a song. They are speaking the language and shows a level of understanding about the level of the business needed. It is a way to be taken more seriously and gaining street credibility. And I am living proof that it expands your co-writing and your personal network. I look at the demo process as one more level of competing on the same playing field as the big boys.

MAB