My experience--limited, remember--has been that most of the Official Types listening to your demo can't (or don't want to) imagine what your song would sound like without "full band treatment." So I try to accommodate the lack of imagination as best I can.

Accordingly, when I have something done in a studio, we'll do it with a band. There will be bass, maybe drums (I can always call it "bluegrass music" and leave the drums out), a "whiny" lead (fiddle, harmonica, accordion, &c.) and a "non-whiny" lead (guitar, banjo, mandolin, &c.)--and I'll let the sound engineer mix the leads around so it sounds distinctive.

The Dark Side (for the Industry) of that lack of imagination is if you do that "full band treatment" on a song, what you end up with, if everybody's good, is something that you can easily put on a record and sell yourself. And I've done that, too.

Joe