Wow this has sure been a lively debate

That said I havre my own opinion about this. I agree with those that say it's theft damn right it is. No one should be downloading music for free not paying the artist for it. Now that said here is the problem.

The RIAA has decided that the value of a song downloaded is give or tak 80 to a dollar worth of value. The artist who recorded that song what do they make? 3 cents. Now I know what you'll say 3 cents is better than nothing. That's true it is. However how many people are going to feel the need to pay 80 cents to download a song when the artist only gets 3 cents? Here in lies the problem.

I don't buy music at all anymore. Do I download it illegaly? I used to and I used to debate it under fair use. That said as I have gotten older I have decided that if I want it bad enough I'll pay for it. That said I don't buy music anymore.

Where this really gets interesting is the sales of cd's. When cd's were first released to the market records and tapes at a premium were 8 to 10 dollars. We were told in those days that the releasing of the compact disc would cut sales prices in half once the technology was out of it's infancy.

The logic followed that cassettes required moving parts and were hader to manufacture plus they required more time to record from a master. Records while easier in some ways were still difficult compared to the seeming ease of cd's. The logic made sense yet the prices of cd's doubled from their original price. Some might site inflation?

I don't think inflation has driven the cost as much. The cost of producing a cd and packaging is roughly (when you make 3 million) $4.50 cents a piece. The markup anywhere from 11 to 15 dollars. some will say well the aritst and all the others that worked on it need to be paid too. While this is true did you know that the artist ends up paying lots of added fees out of their royalties? Touring costs recording costs etc etc ad neasuem. Now what does the RIAA end up with? Everything that's left which is a lot.

Now some will say the RIAA is just an orgonization protecting the right of music companies from BMI to RCA. Yes and no they take a percentage of what's paid to the artist and what's paid to the label as well. Their pockets are literally being lined with money that should go to the aritst or at least the recording company.

My other point is DVD videos. Dvd's started out costing 20 the 30 dollars a piece. It was new technology so this made sense. However movies cost a lot more to produce than most studio albums. Now second run DVD's can be had new for 7 to 10 dollars. And older reissued films can be had from 3-5 dollars. If music followed the same trend you'd be able to buy the eagles greatest hits volume one for 1.99 as it is the going rate is 11 to 15 dollars unless you buy used. Did you know if you buy a music cd used the artist doesn't make any money either?

This may seem long and drawn out so what's my point? My point is i do agree the artist should be paid I agree the recording studio and publisher should get paid. Who don't I think should get paid. THE RIAA. They should leave it to the artist and the record companies to decide how much to charge for their album. They should also let the aritists decide compensation. do you know the RIAA actually goes after artists and recording studios that refuse to pay royalties to them?

I am all for people getting paid for what they do long live sound click and others places where people can get paid a decent amount for their work!
Derek


All the worlds a song and all the people Singers

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pageartist.cfm?bandID=740346