The lady from my state is being crucified as an example to others, like a head on a pike, not to mess with the big boys. Yes, it was illegal--no, the music industry will not prosecute everyone who does it, nor will punishing small fish change much behavior or get the money back.

Think about it. We all got used to recording music onto our own blank cassettes. It was part of normal life. Is there anyone on this board who has not made a mixed tape and given it away, or received one from a friend? Or recorded a videotape of your favorite movie on TV and watched it a few times since? (Man, I still have the old Star Trek episodes...don't tell.) If you were pulled over with a mixed tape in your car, would it occur to you to hide it before the police officer reached your window? Small wonder people share music files and are surprised that someone would come after them.

Meanwhile, modes of entertainment have expanded in all directions. Live music is quaint. Going to see a band involves watching musicians do their thing...for three or four hours, while you stand there or dance or drink or pretend to hear one another talk. Karaoke let's everyone be part of the show, and that appeals to a lot of people. And consider all the different forms of entertainment brought about by sampling and electronics. Consider many of us who write and record our own music, playing every part on a home multitrack system.

Consider someone like Prince who told the music industry to take a hike. He cut them out and did it himself. Radiohead release an entire album for free, knowing it will only spike sales of their other albums. Average Janes and Joes can join a website like SoundClick like I just did yesterday for free...and we can sell our songs with no fuss and share a cut with that company.

So yes, rules are rules...but the game has changed and continues to change before our eyes. I like to see an artist get paid for producing art. But after all the years of seeing great artists getting shut out of the game due to Payola, there is a part of me that secretly enjoys witnessing Payback Time. But I get no joy at all thinking about that one woman with a PC and an internet connection and a lack of better judgment who will now be punished for the rest of her life.

Better destroy those old cassettes.