The farm analogy doesn't work perfectly, but it does work. If I steal a cart full of corn from the farmer, he can't sell it, because it's gone. If a kid steals a download from me, I can still still the song.

However, suppose the farmer has so much corn that he still has tons left even after half the town has stolen his corn. He's going to find that no one wants his corn and he can't sell it. So I agree with Gary.

I have downloaded songs without paying before... but I go to iTunes first. If it's there, I buy it. If not, then I may download it. If the artist and/or record company is too arrogant or stubborn to allow legal downloading, they deserve to have their music downloaded illegally.


Richard MacLemale
Music = http://www.richardmac.com