Originally Posted by Pat Hardy
Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Originally Posted by Pat Hardy
Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
See nothing about udio. Hahaha


I heartily agree. AI music sucks, and some folks can detect it immediately, like some folks have perfect pitch, that kind of thing. I know i can detect AI art (most of the time).

Lol. Yeah, most of it does suck. It's in its infancy remember, drum machiness sucked too when they came out. Now they're so good nobody can tell.

I haven't heard any ai song, or track...that's what wete talking about really, is tracks, not songs. It's production in a bottle, but haven't heard any Ai sing that beats my favorite bands.

There's obviously alot more to it, than just logic.

Ai detectors apparently work by breaking down patterns, Ai prefers to work by the next logical step mode
Humans don't have that trait


I think its main power is in an idea generator, and as im starting to do now, just using Ai as my band., and engineer and producer

People will find a way to label that same thing, it's not though

As far as here, even if we didn't have Ai music section, it would be quite easy to tell if somebody is using Ai.

A different singer and style each song, and most obviously, we already know the people here are using it. And are not paying thousands for every song they post.

I think its a great sketch, allows you to experiment with styles you couldn't have.

I also don't it's written better music than me, it just sounds great.

Does lack vibrancy, you can notice it mostly in rock music

Think about what you are saying, as 'it's an idea generator'.

Any ideas that are not your own and are created by AI cannot be protected by US Copyright.

Do you really want to lie on a government copyright application? The fine is $2500 if caught.

if someone steals your idea you sue and it goes to court, do you want to lie under oath if you have to testify?

Toys like Suno are fun to play with, but I would not be trying to market them in any serious way.

Why? It's just wrong, because push button music cheapens the field, and thus poisons it.


No, please don't try and convince me it is the same thing as using a drum machine.


There is no skill, or talent in AI music and there sure as hell is no humanity.

AI music is for lazy people.

If you want to make inexpensive tracks, use BIAB 'real tracks' at least those are real human recordings.

They are great for cheap demos, but they are not 'AI'. (However, they, too, are not copyrightable).





Well yes I'll lie to the government . They've been lying to me for 74 years . Copywrite a AI song , that kinda funny . Let's build a robot building in Washington DC of robots songs. Yeah sticking lyrics in a box and call yourself a genius . Like that lawyer probably tells herself. AI and robot songs are old news . They'll be a new invention coming that everybody can cry about from people who ride horses and bitch about the Model T.

Last edited by bennash; 5 hours ago.
We’re all built from the same dust and dreams,
Different roads, but the same means.