Originally Posted by JAPOV
Everything you run through Ai is re-sampled, duplicated, categorized and stored by AI... That's how Ai learns and adds detail to its library of genres.
Once you use Ai, you can't separate yourself from the machine; Ai owns you, Ai labels you.

Unless an artist has already resigned his/her self to mind-numbingly generic and over-processed digital crap... why would any legitimate and original songwriter do that?

This topic has already become redundant, Dom... just like you.
"YOU" didn't even write this...

Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Good songwriters will generally produce better songs using Artificial Intelligence (AI) than bad songwriters because AI serves as a tool that amplifies human intent, taste, and experience.

AI excels at pattern recognition, speed, and generating options, but it requires a skilled human to curate, refine, and add emotional depth to the output.Here is how the skill gap persists even with AI:Prompting & Curation (Taste): Good songwriters know what makes a song "good" (e.g., lyrical hooks, emotional authenticity, structural variation).

They can curate AI outputs, selecting the few great lines from a pile of "cheesy" or generic content. Bad songwriters may simply take the first, most cliché output, resulting in formulaic music

The "Human Touch" Gap: While AI can mimic styles, it struggles to infuse music with genuine, nuanced emotion. Skilled songwriters use AI to handle technical tasks (like generating chord progressions or backing tracks) while focusing their energy on the "heart" of the song—real stories, emotional resonance, and lyrical nuance.

Workflow Integration: Experienced songwriters use AI as a collaborator to break writer's block or brainstorm new directions. In contrast, someone without fundamental songwriting skills might treat AI as a "ghostwriter," resulting in a song that lacks a cohesive vision.Editing & Refinement: An expert songwriter knows how to rewrite, rearrange, and edit AI-generated lyrics, transforming them from "AI-sounding" to "their own".

The Key Takeaway: The quality of the final song depends on the human's ability to direct the AI. AI reduces the "friction" of creating music, but it does not replace the artistic decision-making that sets good songwriters apart.

And what about your blues guitar playing is not recycled?

Its not unique because you say or think its somehow diffetent.

Music has been copied forever.

The point of this thread is, why results vary using Ai.

Clear to hear.

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 3 hours ago.