|
3 members (bennash, KyleCrawford, 1 invisible),
100,418
guests, and
6,150
robots. |
|
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
Welcome to the Just Plain Folks forums! You are currently viewing our forums as a Guest which gives you limited access to most of our discussions and to other features.
By joining our free community you will have access to post and respond to topics, communicate privately with our users (PM), respond to polls, upload content, and access many other features. Registration is fast, simple, and absolutely free; so please join our community today!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ana Schon
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/16/26 12:11 AM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Lot Long
by Gary E. Andrews - 11/10/26 11:20 AM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 20,017 Likes: 34
Top 10 Poster
|
OP
Top 10 Poster
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 20,017 Likes: 34 |
You know I actually spent 5 minutes on Suno, wrote a lyric, tricked the machine into following a strict format that produced the song I had in my head almost exactly. I can't post it as it is too similar to a song I actually plan to use for a project, but I am impressed. I am holding out for a version that allows more direct control of melody, (it is close to what I wanted, but without as much nuance as I plan to actually use). Had I thought it would produce a usable result, I would have used a lyric I didn't have plans for.
But wow, even the second of two versions had merit, though it sounded different than I wanted, it had some interesting approaches. I might have to play with it some more.
I have signed up for UDIO as well. I am going to make some videos about A.I. and music and thought I needed to actually play around with it to have a first hand perspective of where it is now. I have played with some stuff not yet on the market that is farther along, but the free public stuff that is out is pretty powerful already and exceeded my expectations. Just wait another year and what is coming will make pro-quality releases available to everyone, if they can work out all the legal issues. My fear is that the same old powers that already own and control the market will keep the good stuff underground for themselves. I think that would be the worst outcome of all, even worse than banning it. Rich and powerful people already have access to technology that will just make them richer and more powerful and if we aren't careful, we won't even get their table scraps. You need to know that anything produced by AI cannot be protected by copyright. What AI does is high quality mediocrity. What AI cannot do is high quality genius, or genius at any quality, because genius at any quality, is beyond the reach of AI. The reason that is true because only inspiration, which is divine inspiration, can produce genius. AI is a machine and machines do not have a soul. Soul is a real thing. I know some are not religious (I'm not a Christian) but soul is real. If you've ever had an out-of-body experience, you'll know it. Anyway, What this means is that AI is bad news for mediocrity, but, in point of fact, damn good news for genius. Genius will become even more rare, and more valuable. What do I mean by Genius? It's like porn, I can't define it, but I know it when I see (hear) it. Hey Jude is genius. In My Life is genius. Blowin' in the Wind is genius. Judy Blue Eyes is genius. Both Sides Now is genius. Bohemian Rhapsody is genius. If (by bread) is genius. Rhapsody in Blue is genius. Kashmir is Genius. Don't Go Changin' is genius. Over The Rainbow is genius, and there are many more. I think what in song, all genius has in common is an incredibly strong melody and lyrics So, congratulations AI, if you've done anything, you have made mediocrity less valuable, and those who made a living from it, their lives more difficult. Personally, I'm against anything that makes the lives of composers, songwriters, lyricists, authors, more difficult, at any level. It's hard enough to make a living in the arts with AI breathing down our necks. Genius will always be just fine. I'm against AI because AI has no soul, it's a machine, a dead thing, and it can only produce what it hears, so it's copyright infringement on a massive scale. Udio and Suno are being sued by the big three for this very reason, and, though I've never sided with the big three, I think they exploit talent, but I hope they crush them, and crush them utterly. Did you know that some people can tell AI from other songs? Some people have that ability. I know one thing I can tell, there are a growing number of youtube videos with AI narration, and I can tell them from live voices, instantly, because they are reading from a printed page, and little things give them away, especially they mispronounce coined words often. Another example, where it was obvious the printed page wrote 'no.4 and they were supposed to say 'number 4, the Ai narrator said "NO 4", see? AI is stupid. It's just a machine. I get AI robocalls all the time, and my first questio to it is always 'are you a robot', at which point they hang up, always hang up when you ask it that question. And don't be fooled by AI robots (Ameca, Sophia, etc) and AI chatbots that are lifelike. It's still not so much Artificial intelligence, it's actually 'simulated intelligence'. Simulated. It's become very clever, of course. Technology is doing some amazing things, but if the day comes when robots take all of our jobs, then whoever is profiting from this technology will have to support us. Because without 'us', there will be no rich people. You are incorrect in your first statement. Anything you create with Suno you own, outright. The A.I. itself (nor the company that created it) cannot create a copyright for those, nor claim infringement. Of course precedence will have to wait for one multi billion dollar corporation to sue another, since few, if any, regular people could ever afford to fight such a case, but if you are the one supplying directions (which will be viewed as an "arrangement," lyrics, melody or any combination of the three, YOU will own the copyright and have legal protection, just as you do with any other original creative participation you have in a song's creation. The only unresolved legal question is can anyone ELSE claim ownership. Since these companies state legally they have NO CLAIM on the resulting work, then you tell me who YOU think can claim ownership? A perfect comparison is when a certain instrument with a signature sound is used to make a recording, the creators of that "tool" can't claim ownership of the sound it produces. Neither can an A.I. company. If somehow the courts decide human participation in the creation of an artistic work no longer deserves copyright protection, then we in fact no longer have a "copyright" at all. Remember, the original creation is simply your property. It is when someone makes a recording, takes a photo or somehow reproduces it (even by broadcasting it) that is when your "right" over any "copy" is applicable. So if it is on YouTube, Spotify, local TV, Radio, or in a club, the rights are protected. Who else do you think has a claim on it? If the answer is no one else, then what are you afraid of? If you added a syllable, a note, a word, or arrangement instructions, you are in and no one else can claim it. There is 1 issue however. If you are infringing on another recording, then you have to prove in court that you own it. It doesn't matter if you have registered it or not. That does NOT grant you ownership. Only a court verdict does. I can send "Let It Be" into the copyright office and get a registration. But I have to defend my status in court regardless. A registration, which can still be created even after the fact, gives you the right to seek more damages, but has no other implication on copyright ownership outside of being a single piece of evidence as part of the entire picture of any given case. Your right is established the moment you fix your creation to a tangible medium. (write it down, type it up, record a version, videotape it etc.) The right you do NOT have, is to infringe on a prior work. That is always about who has the best legal help to win a case and the most convincing documentation of your claim of ownership. This is why you should always try to play the song live, or have someone else do it, or get live airplay etc. with proof of who is in the room, audience etc. to help establish the date of your ownership claim. I you have a video of you playing the song live in 1985, that will overcome any later claim that can't also go back that far. Also consider that two works can be identical and neither infringes. That is if the first creator never made it available to be heard by the creator of the second. Example, if I could 1005 convince a jury that I could not have heard (within "reason" which is the legal precedence) a particular Beatles song, then I create a similar melody, I could not be guilty of infringement, nor could they. But since the Beatles are in the public sphere, unless you grew up on another planet, you are not going to be able to "prove" within reason, that you could not have heard it. A more common example is if I write a song I never play out for anyone, I can't claim someone else heard it and stole it. If I sent a copy (with PROOF) to a label who later releases an infringing version, then I can win. Proof might be acceptance of a certified package with the demo in it, which is why no one ever accepts such a thing at those companies. As for "genius" that is entirely an opinion, not a provable fact, nor does anything have to reach such a "standard" (even though that is NOT a standard as it is not measurable) your choice to make hat claim is not relevant. I may think X is genius, you may think Y is genius, but neither of us can force the other to agree. I have heard some really interesting results that match the best of other things I have heard, and many things I haven't heard, but genius is simply too subjective. Have I heard emotional results? Absolutely. I have made quite a few people cry over songs produced with A.I. I have made people laugh with songs created by A.I. I have made people angry. (because the subject was intended to produce anger over an injustice). Those are powerful emotions that art can bring on, which many would call "genius" on merit. But it is all just an opinion. And opinions are like a-ss-hole-s right? A.I. is just as human created as the sound of a Stradivarius violin. Humans produced those sound emitting devices and someone then used each human creation to make another human creation. Does a synthesizer have a soul? Does a drum have a soul? All are used by "geniuses" to make noises which many later consider to be genius creations. A.I. is a tool, like any instrument, or any DAW or microphone or gizmo that emits a sound after receiving human instruction by way of performance (which is action). Many geniuses will make genius music using any given set of tools. A.I. is simply another tool. In my case, I leave no doubt, even from doubters such as yourself. I upload my work (melody, plus lyric, plus pre recorded material) as the starting point. Then I use the tool to enhance it further. It is like a reverb or a synth patch or a legal sample. All are are used to produce music and have been for a long time. Many have opined the genius of the results using those tools. Dark Side Of The Moon uses a LOAD of gear, samples, effects and technology, to produce a work of "genius" as opinions often agree. But others say "it's rubbish" and neither side can PROVE the other wrong. If I play you a song, especially in the coming years, you will NOT be able to recognize if it is A.I. or not A.I.. So does that ean that genius simply ceases to exist? If you can't tell the difference, then what will you do? Will you simply say NOTHING is genius, or will you admit that if a results sounds like genius to you, it is, no matter how it came to be? Only you can answer that, but no matter your answer, it is 1 opinion worth no more than another empirically. And that is a human argument we always have and we choose to side with whoever we want. Within a year, no one will know if something NEW was made with or without A.I. Just as you already can't be sure if a photo of a human is a real person or A.I. created. People used to think photos captured people's souls because the technology reproduced something that could make a love one feel emotional connection. Music does that too when we hear a recording. When you can't tell the difference, then it will speak to you, or it won't. If I use A.I. today to make a NEW photo of my late mother that was never taken of her, it will evoke human emotion in me. The same as if it did the same thing with my Granddaughter who I see pictures of all the time. Either it makes you FEEL something or it doesn't. But that is in the eye and ear of the beholder only, just like it always has been with art.
Brian Austin Whitney Founder Just Plain Folks jpfolkspro@gmail.com Skype: Brian Austin Whitney Facebook: www.facebook.com/justplainfolks"Don't sit around and wait for success to come to you... it doesn't know the way." -Brian Austin Whitney "It's easier to be the bigger man when you actually are..." -Brian Austin Whitney "Sometimes all you have to do to inspire humans to greatness is to give them a reason and opportunity to do something great." -Brian Austin Whitney
|
|
|
|
We would like to keep the membership in Just Plain Folks FREE! Your donation helps support the many programs we offer including Road Trips and the Music Awards.
|
|
|
Forums118
Topics129,182
Posts1,186,204
Members21,480
| |
Most Online236,505 Jul 1st, 2026
|
|
|
"Our enemies may not be who we think they are. They are not Major Label monopolies. The world will always have 'majors.' They are not big corporations who own everything. The world will always have 'big' ones. Our enemies are not the loud mouthed critics telling us we will fail. The world will always have those too. Our most dangerous enemy is our own quiet acceptance of the fate we perceive these entities have mapped out for us. The only danger is our own complacency, or inactivity, and our willingness to believe so called experts who tell us we 'can't' and that our grim fate is inevitable." -Brian Austin Whitney
|
|
|
|