Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Originally Posted by Pat Hardy
Originally Posted by Brian Austin Whitney
You know I actually spent 5 minutes on Suno, wrote a lyric, tricked the machine into following a strict format that produced the song I had in my head almost exactly. I can't post it as it is too similar to a song I actually plan to use for a project, but I am impressed. I am holding out for a version that allows more direct control of melody, (it is close to what I wanted, but without as much nuance as I plan to actually use). Had I thought it would produce a usable result, I would have used a lyric I didn't have plans for.

But wow, even the second of two versions had merit, though it sounded different than I wanted, it had some interesting approaches. I might have to play with it some more.

I have signed up for UDIO as well. I am going to make some videos about A.I. and music and thought I needed to actually play around with it to have a first hand perspective of where it is now. I have played with some stuff not yet on the market that is farther along, but the free public stuff that is out is pretty powerful already and exceeded my expectations. Just wait another year and what is coming will make pro-quality releases available to everyone, if they can work out all the legal issues. My fear is that the same old powers that already own and control the market will keep the good stuff underground for themselves. I think that would be the worst outcome of all, even worse than banning it. Rich and powerful people already have access to technology that will just make them richer and more powerful and if we aren't careful, we won't even get their table scraps.


You need to know that anything produced by AI cannot be protected by copyright. What AI does is high quality mediocrity. What AI cannot do is high quality genius, or genius at any quality, because genius at any quality, is beyond the reach of AI. The reason that is true because only inspiration, which is divine inspiration, can produce genius. AI is a machine and machines do not have a soul. Soul is a real thing. I know some are not religious (I'm not a Christian) but soul is real. If you've ever had an out-of-body experience, you'll know it. Anyway, What this means is that AI is bad news for mediocrity, but, in point of fact, damn good news for genius. Genius will become even more rare, and more valuable. What do I mean by Genius?

It's like porn, I can't define it, but I know it when I see (hear) it. Hey Jude is genius. In My Life is genius. Blowin' in the Wind is genius. Judy Blue Eyes is genius. Both Sides Now is genius. Bohemian Rhapsody is genius. If (by bread) is genius. Rhapsody in Blue is genius. Kashmir is Genius. Don't Go Changin' is genius. Over The Rainbow is genius, and there are many more. I think what in song, all genius has in common is an incredibly strong melody and lyrics

So, congratulations AI, if you've done anything, you have made mediocrity less valuable, and those who made a living from it, their lives more difficult. Personally, I'm against anything that makes the lives of composers, songwriters, lyricists, authors, more difficult, at any level. It's hard enough to make a living in the arts with AI breathing down our necks.

Genius will always be just fine. I'm against AI because AI has no soul, it's a machine, a dead thing, and it can only produce what it hears, so it's copyright infringement on a massive scale. Udio and Suno are being sued by the big three for this very reason, and, though I've never sided with the big three, I think they exploit talent, but I hope they crush them, and crush them utterly.

Did you know that some people can tell AI from other songs? Some people have that ability. I know one thing I can tell, there are a growing number of youtube videos with AI narration, and I can tell them from live voices, instantly, because they are reading from a printed page, and little things give them away, especially they mispronounce coined words often. Another example, where it was obvious the printed page wrote 'no.4 and they were supposed to say 'number 4, the Ai narrator said "NO 4", see? AI is stupid. It's just a machine. I get AI robocalls all the time, and my first questio to it is always 'are you a robot', at which point they hang up, always hang up when you ask it that question.

And don't be fooled by AI robots (Ameca, Sophia, etc) and AI chatbots that are lifelike. It's still not so much Artificial intelligence, it's actually 'simulated intelligence'. Simulated. It's become very clever, of course. Technology is doing some amazing things, but if the day comes when robots take all of our jobs, then whoever is profiting from this technology will have to support us. Because without 'us', there will be no rich people.

There are no laws yet preventing anyone from copyrighting a song done by Ai, on top of that, nobody will know if you used AI or not. Especially if using only bits of it to your advantage

Yeah, I can tell difference between ai and not, it's obvious here, but there are subtitles in timing and in pronunciation.

Ai also tends to go off on tangents that humans woundnt do. But organic music for now is still better and safe

Some people are legitimately concerned about AI not just music but all walks of life.

If ai saves money and is better, it's going to happen.

Perhaps the one thing us humans have to do is prevent AI from being able to function without us.

Programmers could maybe save the day.

But I think for several hundred years AI will not take over. Thousand years very possible

I guarantee that there are A.I. results which you would be unable to determine between that result and a studio result. If we lined up 5 A.I. results and 5 studio made results of the same song you had never heard, there is nearly a zero chance (above literal random guessing) that you would correctly pick the 5 real from the 5 A.I. And A.I. is still in baby step territory. Sure, I can tell among work I am familiar with easily, but once it is a new result matched by new studio results, it is already VERY difficult to tell. I would love to do such a test among the naysayers to see if they could tell the difference. I recently played a version of an old song that I wrote with a wah wah guitar part that my friend thought was himself. He literally did not realize it was his own playing. And frankly it was a good result, but obvious to me, but of course I made it. If I was hearing a bunch of old recordings I had not heard in 30 years I doubt I would have known what was me playing keys and not me. It just did a "cover" version of ME playing a piano solo which I knew wasn't me, but which sounded just like me, outside of a variation it did on the actual performance simply staying in key, but putting notes in a different order within a passage. It was jaw dropping to me because there is no way in a blind test 30 years apart, I would have known which was mine and which was A.I. The rest of the song, sure, but not that specific passage.

One day soon, the A.I. will make as many random mistakes as humans (by design) and then unless you were involved in the creation, you won't be able to tell the difference. Then the result will have to be judged on merit. These same arguments were made by the same people, but on the other side, who first embraced synthesizers and samplers. Now you can hear classical music recorded with expert musicians which as impossible to decide which is live piano and which is a sampled piano and only the highest level trained ears can tell if a human interpreted the sheet music or a computer. A.I. is just another such tool. Frankly no one cares if a piano sound is a real mic'd piano or a sampled piano. Soon, no one will care if A.I. was used either. Kids already do not care.


Brian Austin Whitney
Founder
Just Plain Folks
jpfolkspro@gmail.com
Skype: Brian Austin Whitney
Facebook: www.facebook.com/justplainfolks

"Don't sit around and wait for success to come to you... it doesn't know the way." -Brian Austin Whitney

"It's easier to be the bigger man when you actually are..." -Brian Austin Whitney

"Sometimes all you have to do to inspire humans to greatness is to give them a reason and opportunity to do something great." -Brian Austin Whitney