I find it funny how quickly people jump to conclusions and call something a scam without any background information. I can provide some background information since it's my company that is being talked about, the same company that provided a FREE song production for Everett a few months ago. You're welcome, by the way. 

As most of you know, we're an online music production company most and foremost. However, recently we started to provide a free pre-screening service for a few publishers and libraries and a free song submission service to songwriters. Yes, FREE. I don't know any other company out there that provides this for free. Most charge a per song fee or an annual membership fee, or both. We don't. Why you may wonder. 

Well, we do this free of charge for publishers and libraries to build a relationship with them, create value and hopefully be able to charge for the service in the future. If that doesn't happen, it will pay off in some form or shape, be it through intros, or through help with getting into publishing ourselves. Fundraising for our next capital raise, etc. etc. 

We do this free of charge for songwriters because, first of all, we don't believe in "pay for play" and secondly, it builds a relationship with songwriters and hopefully, if and when a songwriter who uses our submission service requires professional music production services, he/she may favor us over a competing business. As we all know, you have to give before you take. 

You all know, most publishers (especially those worth pursuing) have a strict "no unsolicited submissions" policy. We happen to have a relationship with a few publishers and can provide songwriters with suitable material a foot in the door to these publishers and make their submissions "solicited". 

Having said all that and going back to the original question, yes, we do require the sheet music. We also require the lyrics sheet, uncompressed wav files of the song, the instrumental and all stems as well as confirmation that the submitter is legally authorized to submit the song(s) and owns all rights, including the publishing. This isn't something we came up with, but our publishing partners asked us to provide. 

Here is why: More than once, it happened that we forwarded a song, the publisher likes it, reaches out to the songwriter to sign a publishing contract only to find out that he/she actually doesn't have the stems, doesn't have the sheet music, doesn't own the publishing rights, etc. 

What a massive waste of our time, the publisher's time and the songwriter's time. So, we all decided to cover ALL bases during the submission phase to avoid this in the future. I admit, the sheet music is rarely needed, but it is needed often enough, one of the partners we work with ALWAYS wants the sheet music. 

Yes, we do provide a service to create the sheet music but, we don't care where the sheet music is being created and even prefer if the songwriter creates it him/herself. To be honest with you, creating sheet music of a song we did not create is a royal pain and super time consuming. Considering what we charge for that service, it certainly isn't worth our time and we'd be much happier (and more profitable) spending that time on production projects, but some clients asked us to transcribe their songs, so we added it to our services. 

To finish this mini rant, I don't think it's unreasonable to ask a songwriter for sheet music in the first place. I mean, come on, you write music, hoping to sell it and don't want to (or can't) provide the "manual" to your piece you want to sell. Maybe that's just me, but when I still actively wrote songs (many moons ago), I always created the sheet music for the songs I ended up recording professionally. I obviously didn't bother for the demos and scratch tapes, but I had sheet music for EVERY SINGLE PROFESSIONALLY PRODUCED song. 

One more thing I can assure you is, when a professional songwriter orders a song production on our platform, the songwriter provides us with a work tape, the lyrics and the sheet music (or at least a chord sheet) while new songwriters or those who just write music for fun don't. 

So, maybe some publishers/libraries we work with use the chord sheet request to separate songwriters who are serious about their craft from the ones who aren't? I don't know, just a theory. 

This question goes to John and Marc, both of you are professional songwriters, as in make a full time living with it (correct me if I'm wrong). Even though you stated that sheet music isn't (always) needed, do you have the sheet music of the songs you actually place? I don't want to put any words into your mouth and I certainly can't tell if you're being truthful with your answers, but I would be surprised if the answer was "no". 

At the end of the day, yes, there are a whole lot of sketchy players in the music industry (or any industry highly in demand). But not all of them are. Calling something a scam without knowing the company and without knowing the background of why something is being done the way it's being done is simply wrong. And honestly, I explained the above (abbreviated in an email) to Evertt but I guess it's the typical case of "I just hear what I want to hear". Probably the reason why so many songwriters are so "CONVINCED OF THE VALIDITY OF THEIR SONGS" as Marc rightly put it. 


https://tunedly.com

Contact me at chris@tunedly.com