Hi All:

I've been following this thread since Everett's first post. Initially, the idea presented "swims upstream" from what most of us have experienced here at JPF and other music sites. It is very unusual for a publisher, artist or producer to require a full-blown combination of sheet-music and lyrics these days... but the practice was pretty common about twenty years ago to ward off amateurs and other "time-wasters."

The advent of the Internet has brought about many changes. Now, most "potential clients" require only a lyric sheet and an MP3 recording. (Some want the chords with the lyrics... but few want the sheet music.) The more demanding requirements usually occur when the screening process determines that the song or composition being "pitched" is acceptable to the client or website involved.

Chris, I hope we are not seemingly ungrateful for the opportunity to use a new platform with requirements we are not used to seeing. We (as a group) are generally very skeptical because we have been bombarded with "baited hooks" so many times before. When Marc (our resident Nashville Insider) confirms our suspicions, we are even more pre-prejudiced about what appears to be something dark and murky. If I read your reply correctly, you still would accept a lyric and chord sheet?

The conflict between us is widened when we hear old-timers here (like Roy Cooper) defending you and your platform. John S. is probably the most successful here at creating income from compositions that are scooped up quickly by advertisers, documentary creators and movie makers. He has experience with Libraries and all the quirky ins-and-outs of knowing which ones are legitimate and which ones lure us out onto thin ice.

So Chris, please forgive us if we appear to be throwing the "Baby out with the Bath-Water." Welcome to JPF and please feel free to explain more about how your organization works and makes money. Sorry if we seem ungrateful.

Best regards and wishes for success in this ever-changing business.

----Dave Rice