"This question goes to John and Marc, both of you are professional songwriters, as in make a full time living with it (correct me if I'm wrong). Even though you stated that sheet music isn't (always) needed, do you have the sheet music of the songs you actually place? I don't want to put any words into your mouth and I certainly can't tell if you're being truthful with your answers, but I would be surprised if the answer was "no"."

Hello,
I can't speak for John, but in my case, no, sheet music has never been asked for in the songs I've placed. But unless songs are a major hit, in a collection such as songbooks, etc. sheet music is never called for. I have had on two occassions had sheet music included on my songs, but was for a specific purpose, used in conjunction with a teaching piano song book, and that was done by the publisher of the song book. In the Nashville industry mostly country, there is no need for it, again, unless it becomes a major hit and is used in compilation song books, or in teaching uses. And if that is needed, usually the publisher provides it, but almost always after the fact.

As I had said, I have never heard of it outside of things like Christian music, or hit songs, again where song books, teaching instruction manuals, etc. might be involved. But again, that is usually done after the fact. I had never heard of an example where a publisher was asking for it before listening to a song. That was where I was coming from. Each publisher, song plugger, whatever is going to have their own requirements in their own needs. It's why I really don't like using the term "scam." and I probabaly should not have used it in this case without knowing more information. So I apologize for doing what I tell other people not to do, jump too quickly to conclusions before getting all the facts from all sides. I should practice what I preach. Not all things are scams, and might just have different requirements than most of us are familiar with. Each person needs to get to know who they are dealing with, build a relationship and then make a decision on what they are interesting in providing.

Hearing your explanation makes sense in your application, and glad you provided it. Just something I personally had not heard of, and is not part of our particular region.

MAB

Last edited by Marc Barnette; 06/25/20 09:36 AM.