Hi, Jen! This one is absolutely beautiful... I thought so from your original post! And now that it is really taking nice form with the melody, I just wanted to share some thoughts about your re-write, kos.

As is, James is singing the last 4 lines of V1 somewhat like a Pre-Chorus. So, I am wondering if your new V2 really adds anything new, unique or necessary all by itself except to lengthen the song, which may be too much when it's all put together. Then, V3 beginning with "Which leads me.." is going to be a little strange no matter what coming right out of the Chorus. This verse worked well the way it was originally written, but now will have a disconnected start.

I suggest combining your new V2 & V3, in a way that will allow him to sing the Pre-Chorus melody twice, the first building into the second, and then booming into the Chorus. Then, he can sing the bridge, and Boom back into the Chorus again for the ending... in my mind, that plays out powerfully.

Here's my suggestion at how to combine, keeping almost all the elements you already have here (I think I've only tweaked a bit, and again take or leave, or change to your liking):

V2
Changing seasons left me behind
Which led me here today
So that I could share with you
One secret I couldn't say
(Pre-Chorus/Build)
You see I haven't done
All I set out to do
I can't go through motions/emotions
Without saying this
Without saying this to you
(Pre-Chorus)
I've loved you more than anyone
Perhaps you always knew
And I have often wondered if
You may have
You may have
You may have loved me, too.

Good luck with it! It really is beautiful, and I like the mystery. I don't think this one needs everything to be spoon-fed!

--Jen


The dictionary is the only place where success comes before work.--Mark Twain