To me it's obvious she has star quality. I think she's very talented, very personable and I hope she goes on to even greater success - though she already seems to be near the top. smile

I'll never be a fan. It is true I was moved by her performance at the Grammys (interesting because that is what she is being criticized for) but that was more the performance and less the songs.

Big deal - I'll never be a fan of Justin Timberlake either - and he has star quality.

As long as it's not TOO big a perturbation from what you like, recognizing talent should be independent of whether it is your favorite music or not.....imo, anyway....

Scott