Acoustically, there are two sounds I like depending on their application. For chord comping, like a jazz tune or such, I like a more complex tone rich in overtones that add a warm smooth, not too bright or in your face sound.

For fingerpicking and most of what I do, which is accompany myself on my Americana sort of tunes, I like a strong fundamental tone, that is rounded, but not too complex. I want to get a full rich tone on the lower strings in the 3rd to 10th frets, not thin and flat, but capable of singing out. I do not want too bright, with no mid or bottom to round out the sound. That is probably the least musical sound to my ears. I could point out the type of guitars that produce the sounds I am referring to, but you said no brand names.

On electric guitars, I think it really depends on the tunes getting played, but most of the time, I like the tone to be bright and distinctive without piercing the ears, with a little bit of edge. I like it so that when I get it on a little I can hear the edge begin to kick in naturally, instead of just there all the time. Sometimes for certain songs I might like a thick smooth crunch for a rhythm to anchor something like a 12 bar blues tune.