Mr Dawg, Not exactly sure of the changes you have made, but now I get it. I really respect your courage to write about this situation, I lost my father in a similar way-he would say 'they can keep you alive, but it's not living..."
Personally, I don't think you need the first verse- tearjerkers work best for me when they're short eg elanor rigby, the less you say, the more powerful the remaining words become.
Very nice, you have to dig deep to get the good ones out. Mike