As someone said already, we're not going to change each other's minds on this one.

But I'd like to throw in a few thoughts. How come kids are willing to pay $2 for a ringtone but not pay 99 cents for the full track? They do so more or less willingly, and in increasingly big numbers. Revenue from ringtones now outstrips singles sales in the UK.

How have we so diminished the perceived value of recorded music? i-Tunes shows that in the right format, enough people have no problem coughing up for something they like. Why don't we consider that rather than running flame wars and (the RIAA equivalent) crucifying music fans, the people that swamp the lyric sites with requests (n° 28 in word searches this week apparently).

The record industry tried to block the development of music on the web, and is paying the price. It deserves everything that has hit it (and I say this as someone that derives an income from it). It has been unable to respond to consumer demand by offering a valid product in an accessible format. It really is that simple. All the other debates are distracting us and wasting our time.

I don't condone file-sharing as you describe it, but I understand it. For years already, it has been increasingly difficult to purchase music that I like - which is usually one-off singles or tracks or even old 30s stuff that I like. So obviously some bright sparks started creating systems to share files. There was a vacuum and - whoosh - no more vacuum.

Whether it is right or wrong is totally irrelevant. It's there and we're not going backwards. So personally I'd be looking to the labels and publishers that are willing to work with the downloaders rather than 50 year-olds that are still hankering for Ye Olde Record Shoppe and the Good Old Days of Radio. Those days ain't coming back, but there's a whole new dawn on its way. So please point me in the direction of the businessman that can monetarise this new generation. I'm up for it.

------------------
Michael Leahy
The Accidental Lyricist
http://michael-leahy.indiegroup.com


Michael Leahy
The Accidental Lyricist
http://www.a-lyric.com/