Originally Posted by bennash
Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Well, I understand why musicians and songwriters are against it, because it allows for anybody to make music, the talentless, the tone deaf, can all be songwriters.

So if your not a songwriter, why do you feel the need to be one.

Again these are general feelings on it.

I mean, I cant use Ai to become a basketball player, or a bow and arrow shooter, or dancer...

Why should I be able to be a songwriter . If I cant sing why shoukd I now be a singer through ai

So I get the points on both sides of the coin

Basicly the entry barrier to making music is now gone. Nobody should sound like [naughty word removed], if your lyrics suck, the music is still gonna carry it, and make yiu sound competent.

My take is this. The majority of Ai music I've heard, here or anywhere, is very basic and borders on mediocre.

I have not been floored by any song as I have the Beatles, the who, Paul Simon, Billy Joel, these guys still are better, and by a wide margin.

It basically is a welcome mat to mediocrity.

But its a massive upgrade to those with no talent.

The better artist should still make better art.


https://nashvillecalifornia.com/how-can-humans-be-so-smart-and-so-stupid/

I think theres collateral damage using Suno without getting humans involved . It effects us all with a trickle down effect, If 2 communities are supported Suno and session players . The moral code is not broken .
Thou shall not steal can be taken off the contributor resume. I'm going to be so fucking smart when I die , Even Einstein will be impressed .

You're not as dumb as I thought Ben...

I think the main answer is this..

So how can humans be so smart and so stupid at the same time?

Because the human brain evolved to help us survive on the African plains. Fight and flight response, which even today, millions of years layer shows up as Ulcers, heart attacks, strokes.

Our brains were not designed to do the math of the cosmos, or to learn the physics that caused us to exist...

We weren't wondering, if this Sabre tooth tiger might be friendly. We ran the [naughty word removed] away to remove all doubt. That's why deer and rabbits no chances when they see us.

But, we used our big brain to go from incoherent monkeys into suit wearing execs.

We learned the weather wasn't God, that the wrath was not the center of the universe, that aliens can never get here cause of distance.

We mastered tech and invention, became great at medicine and surgery.

But deep down, were still animals. We still think with our dicjks, enough that some of the smartest men ever, will throw everything away to get some poosie.

There is a difference between cerebral intelligence and emotional intelligence.

Poker players are masters of not letting emotions dictate what they decide.

Crime, murder, wars, all have emotional cores.

Emotions can over power intelligence

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 08/12/26 04:55 PM.