Originally Posted by Sunset Poet
Originally Posted by Brian Austin Whitney
All non label or non published songwriters will get screwed over and it is already happening. The labels and publishers (often the same companies) will steal 100% of the control and income even though they only represent <1% music makers. They did it with Spotify, they are doing it again with A.I. companies. Most of ALL the training of A.I. is NOT using label artists, it is using JPF members and other indie artists who will not get representation nor a share of any of the money. Major artists have too few songs recorded to train A.I.

You have stated that the labels and publishers are going to "screw over" artists and many others.
If the labels and publishers own a musical catalogue, they have a right to pursue the protection of it, the liquidation of it, or whatever else they want to do with. Including negotiate with SUNO and UDIO. It would be a breach of the constitution to tell them they could not..

If there is this massive group of musical copyright holders out there without sway (99%?) , then they are going to get washed around in the tides created by the big players.No news there. Never has been.

JAY Z and Beyonce were part of a group that was going to wrestle back control of their music from SPOTIFY and the streamers. It failed because the typical Beyonce and JAY Z fan wants their music for nothing. The root of most of this particular evil is the fan who wants everything for free.

WAYPO et al looks ready to destroy Yellow CAB and UBER.
COSTCO, WALMART and China have wreaked havok on Main street and American manufacturing.
AI appears to be about to up-end civilization, leaving so many people out of a job, I don't see how its possible not to have anarchy throughout the world.

If you were the head of a major label, your job would be to maintain the viability and profitability of your company.
You would have a right to take whatever steps you felt necessary to do that within the law. You and your company would also be victims of the tides. I'm sure the labels would return to an only-vinyl world if they could.

And you would do it to, just like the label heads do.

Constantly framing them as, "the man" and "the conspiracy"and "the screwer-over-ers" is not going to move any needles because it reflects a distorted reality that doesnt connect all of the dots.

You apparently don't know much about how things really work. I have battled these people directly. I got a standing ovation in Washington D.C. at an open hearing when I pointed out that the RIAA and other people negotiating for digital royalties claimed they represented 80% of writers and artists, but I pointed out the ACTUAL math that in truth it is less than 1%. By example, I used just our 125K members at the time and how at the same time, the sum total of EVERY SINGLE artist those "negotiation" actually represented was under 1K. And JPF is a literal drop in the bucket of worldwide music makers. Yet, these politicians would NOT give a voice or representation to the ACTUAL collective of music creators who these laws and rates forever effect. They literally were left speechless in response while the audience erupted in a long ovation.

The reality is these power players know 100% it is a scam, yet they do it because their influence and money allows it to. The reality of A.I. music training is that most of it happened with indie content on Spotify, iTunes, Soundcloud, YouTube and Tik Tok. But, the truth is that humans learn just the way A.I. does. They listen to OTHER creators, mimic their styles and sounds and process them in THEIR computer (their brain) and spit it back out through the filter of their talent and intent. A.I. does much the same. It's a blender of all those approaches. Then common points of style and approach inform their output. There is ZERO way to demonstrate which, if any, songs are being infringed on, unless an ACTUAL infringement occurs. But the A.I. is trained NOT to copy any specific song lyric or melody. Ironically, it is better at NOT infringing on copyrights than humans are.

Good luck to anyone trying to prove infringement by an A.I. because in truth, ALL music is a copy of the sum of what came before, either by direct influence, or cumulative influence. EVERYTHING infringes in the same way A.I. infringes.

This is the same argument of a synth playing a violin sounds versus a human. In this case it is a computer algorithm writing production of music verses a human doing it. The influences are simply wider and more inclusive than the normal human.

Elites and Corporations have power and that level of power is corrupt. It exploits humans at every turn to accumulate power and wealth. Politicians allowing such interests to set rates or laws for EVERYONE which ALWAYS directly benefit ONLY their interests over all others is 100% corrupt. It is neither Democracy or what should be allowed by OUR Government, a constitutional Republic. So yes, Elites are by nature, corrupt. Corporations are by nature ALSO corrupted, some worse than others. Individuals should be given the power of 1. Corporations should receive ZERO power from government, but that is not what happens. It is also why we are 36+ trillion in unpayable debt where over 1 trillion in interest are going to corrupt bankers who immorally have power over our monetary system plus all the corrupt politicians who allow it to continue. It IS us versus THEM. "the man" is the shorthand for this corruption. It IS a conspiracy because more than 1 party has conspired to achieve and use this immoral and corrupt power.


Brian Austin Whitney
Founder
Just Plain Folks
jpfolkspro@gmail.com
Skype: Brian Austin Whitney
Facebook: www.facebook.com/justplainfolks

"Don't sit around and wait for success to come to you... it doesn't know the way." -Brian Austin Whitney

"It's easier to be the bigger man when you actually are..." -Brian Austin Whitney

"Sometimes all you have to do to inspire humans to greatness is to give them a reason and opportunity to do something great." -Brian Austin Whitney