Originally Posted by Fdemetrio
Originally Posted by Brian Austin Whitney
Also beware:

For those who think they can upload this A.I. stuff as a commercial product, even though legally you CAN do it, beware. I am starting to see common orchestration techniques with my songs where backing melodies and riffs are used over and over. It may happen in human created music, but the A.I. seems to repeat stuff that sounds really cool (usually outside your original melody) in the background of tracks. I can see where this will end in lawsuits if any label backed act has that riff or musical hook line and then your A.I. music ALSO has it. Or, when A.I. creations start getting sued by OTHER A.I. creations. Then it is simply about who has the most money to buy justice.

I thought maybe it was just "my" choice that led to these common styles in my own music, but for the first time I heard an exact riff on a friends new song which has the same exact riff as one of my songs from 4 months ago. THAT is a problem! Humans cop riffs all the time, but once lawsuits start to fly, A.I. creators are going to be in trouble. I have gone back and redone some of my favorite tracks recently to remove certain musical flourishes (again, that I love) to try and protect from future issues. My melodies and words are not the danger, it is counter melodies and signature riffs provide by A.I. that are an issue.

I will repost this as it's own post to folks might see it.

Well, that's what I've been saying since day one. It creates based on what's been done already. Riffs and counter melodies can be "composed" too

But if you choose to let AI do it, maybe you just write lyrics , so it's what demo services have been doing forever.

They don't work weeks on their filler riffs and melodies, more like on the fly saying....good enough.

I think the bigger lawsuits are when it steals from hit songs, uses likenesses of singers voices, mimicks a band sound. I'm sure I could get it to play a u2 production, and it basically be playing a u2 record with my lyric.

Everything is stolen with ai.

And, ironically, it learns, so anything we put into it , it can use that for somebody else's work.

Especially weird if you have a very unique lyric idea, that will be used partly in something else.

So not only will it steal from famous artists, it will steal our ideas too

This has ALWAYS been a problem even with top session players. If you are not an A list client, you get the B list riffs from the catalog they have of them. Legal precedence protects say a session player who plays similar riffs on many songs, because they can't "plagiarize" themselves. So I am guessing if he plays the same riff on two recordings, on won't be able to sue the other. But with A.I., none of that will apply.

It has gotten worse. A.I. has now copied MY melody from one song to an entirely different song in a different genre with different lyrics. Even the key is different, but it is IDENTICAL. I have created a "problem" playlist with 2 blatant infringement examples. I upload my own songs to start each session, but this used my own recording on a different song, on another. So that likely means it is doing it across artists. I also got a result that was random but it included 2 bad demo quality recordings of another song entirely. At first I chalked it up to being a dud. But then I realized it was someone else's song! It wasn't good, but it was clearly a finished song demo they had uploaded. I am trying to find it in my rejected tracks. I have done over 7000 songs and I don't remember which one I was working on when that happened.

Has anyone else had this happen?

Brian

Brian Austin Whitney
Founder
Just Plain Folks
jpfolkspro@gmail.com
Skype: Brian Austin Whitney
Facebook: www.facebook.com/justplainfolks

"Don't sit around and wait for success to come to you... it doesn't know the way." -Brian Austin Whitney

"It's easier to be the bigger man when you actually are..." -Brian Austin Whitney

"Sometimes all you have to do to inspire humans to greatness is to give them a reason and opportunity to do something great." -Brian Austin Whitney