Originally Posted by John Lawrence Schick
"You just repeated what I said. That's what you did here" - Fdemetrio

Oh, is this what you said Fdemetrio: "Being different just for the sake of being different isn’t what I mean. Music needs to be intelligible. It needs form. A random blur of jamming doesn’t constitute music. You’re example of being different is simply noise. Not valid as intelligible music".

I must have missed you saying the same thing. laugh
FD
In order for any piece of music to be recognized as music, and somebody says " hey I hear music"

It has to be similar to any other music.

Sure you can go wacky and and intentionally try to choose something weird or off kilter, but why?

JLS
Being different just for the sake of being different isn’t what I mean. Music needs to be intelligible. It needs form. A random blur of jamming doesn’t constitute music. You’re example of being different is simply noise. Not valid as intelligible music.

Same thing...

And your piece is exactly what you said above

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 12/10/24 12:58 PM.